It’s understandable that many investors would be interested in a monthly income investment during this everlasting low-interest rate environment but the investments or products are not without their pitfalls. You need to choose wisely and understand how the income is generated.
The low-interest rate is a challenge for retirees who grew up with higher interest and bond rates. The payout on their investment was juicy in the 80s and now it’s not and the income is still needed. There was a point in time when a fixed income portfolio would suffice but it’s not the case anymore. Fixed income is used to balance risk rather than provide the necessary income that it used to provide. I know for a fact as I have seen my parents switch towards equity from juicy fixed income investments. Government and municipal bonds were great and now preferred shares are their replacement for some investors. Even those have changed their payout and equities provide better returns but with it comes the risk.
You can either invest in the separate investment options or buy products such as mutual funds or ETFs built to provide monthly income. Have you ever walked into a bank and seen the offer of $600 per month for $100,000 in investment? That’s how they advertise their products. Other strategies are employed and different mixed of assets are put together and offered through many different products such as BMO Monthly Income Fund or ETF.
Monthly Income Generation
Let’s be clear, generating monthly income is not complicated when you know the available strategies. However, choosing the best option at the right time is not always easy.
Buying and holding the bond coupon on your own doesn’t usually lead to monthly income. Bonds payment are often every 3 months or semi-annually. Buying bonds is also a different process than buying blue chip stocks. If you are not used to it, you may be more interested in a Bond mutual fund or ETF which can be setup to pay monthly income.
Take for example the iShares 1-5 Year Laddered Government Bond Index ETF (TSE:CLF) which currently provide a 3.17% distribution yield. You may be tempted by the yield based on the current interest rates but look at the price history. Who said fixed income was less risky than a stock? Interest rates have a major impact on bond rates and since coupons are sold for a fixed time, you end up needing to either wait with the fixed rate or sell on the secondary market which is then based on offer and demand.
Another important point to look at is that the yield is expected to go down. Look at the high yield coupons and their expiry dates, they are all expiring in the short term horizon so it only means that the yield will go down over time unless interest rates go up. Not that simple anymore to get consistent monthly income. You might be better to learn how to buy bonds on your own.
In a tax-free account (TFSA, RRSP or RESP), all yields are equals (aside from the foreign withholding tax) but in a taxable account, it is not the same. See dividends vs distribution for more details on the tax implications. If you needed to hold non-qualified dividends in a taxable account, the yield comparison needs to take into account your taxes for it to be a fair comparison.
While the majority of companies pay a quarterly dividend, there are equities that pay monthly dividends. In fact, I track 20 monthly dividends paying stock in the Canadian Dividend Screener. Below are 2 examples of large corporations maintaining a consistent and growing monthly dividend. It usually means that cash flow is relatively consistent and possibly represent subscription or recurring type of revenue. You cannot promise monthly dividend not knowing you have the cash coming in monthly, where would the financial accountability be otherwise. Investors would simply not buy those investments.
Shaw Communications is a leading network company and one of the largest providers of residential communication services in Canada.
The company serves 3.2 million subscribers, including 1.9 million internet and more than one million Shaw home phone customers. It owns an extensive network of 860,000 kilometers long fiber network providing data networking, video, voice, and Internet services to companies of all sizes.
Shaw Communications has a presence in both wireline (80% of revenue) and wireless (20%) segments. The wireline division consists of consumer and business services. The wireless division provides wireless voice and data services through its mobile wireless network infrastructure.
Shaw Communications operates through a large hybrid fiber-coax networks and an expanding wireless retail distribution infrastructure in collaboration with retail partners like Walmart and Loblaws. Its strategic partnership with industry leaders like Comcast, Nokia and Cisco and seamless connectivity experience are its strong competitive advantages.Investment Data
- Opportunity Score: 50
- Ticker: TSE:SJR.B
- Sector: Communication Services
- Industry: Telecommunication Services
- Market Cap: 8.98B
- P/E: 16.82
- Dividend Yield: 5.32%
- Payout Ratio (Earnings): 89.77%
- Canadian Dividend Aristocrat: NO
- Chowder Score: Members Only
- Revenue Growth: Members Only
- Dividend Growth: Members Only
- Dividend Growth Fit: 2/10
- Dividend Income Fit: 5/10
Distribution is where it gets interesting as anything that is not considered a qualified dividend as per Canadian regulations is a distribution with the perspective of a mutual fund or dividend ETF. When a fund has bonds that pay what is the equivalent of interest, the fund cannot call that dividend, it uses the term distribution to bundle all the money it gives back to shareholders.
Covered calls are an advanced income generating strategy. It’s another way to earn an income from your holdings on top of a possible dividend. It’s like double dipping. I won’t go into details are as it’s an options trading strategy that limits your upside while protecting your downside.
Return of Capital
This is an interesting one. You generate income by getting your money back. It’s like a withdrawal of your initial capital rather than a capital gain. When this happens, the adjusted cost base (ACB) needs to be adjusted. It’s often used with mutual funds and ETFs to maintain the promised distribution.
This refers to take your profits which can be used to pay the distribution in a mutual fund or ETF. In some cases, there are regular purchase and disposition of holdings which triggers capital gains (or losses).
Monthly Income Funds & ETFs
Banks are in the business of making money so they jumped at the opportunity to offer monthly income funds or ETFs as outlined below. Not all of them are created equal and yet they have the same purpose and are being bought by many investors.
Let’s have a look at the popular Monthly Income Funds and Monthly Income ETFs and what makes them what they are. One interesting point is that distribution yield is not widely advertised on the bank’s website or even the Globe & Mail investor section.
What is important to understand is that all the monthly income generation method mentioned above are used in the products outlined below. Most of them own very similar content as you can see and yet they have varied distribution yield.
The mutual funds tend to balance bonds and equity to deliver their results
BMO Monthly Income Fund
BMO Monthly Income Fund (fund details) is the most expensive monthly income fund outlined here with a 1.57% MER.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.024
- Annual Distribution: $0.5878
- Annual Distribution Yield: 7.94%
CIBC Monthly Income Fund
CIBC Monthly Income Fund (fund details) has an MER of 1.47% with a very different set of holdings than the BMO Monthly Income Fund.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.06
- Annual Distribution: $0.72
- Annual Distribution Yield: 5.95%
RBC Monthly Income Fund
RBC Monthly Income Fund (fund details) has an MER of 1.20%. It tracks the bond index along with the TSX capped composite.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.0425
- Annual Distribution: $0.51
- Annual Distribution Yield: 3.62%
Scotia Diversified Monthly Income Fund
Scotia Diversified Monthly Income Fund (fund details) has an MER of 1.46%.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.03
- Annual Distribution: $0.5695
- Annual Distribution Yield: 5.13%
TD Monthly Income Fund
TD Monthly Income Fund (fund details) has an MER of 1.47%. This fund has the lowest yield of all and one of the lowest exposure to bonds
- Monthly Distribution: $0.0299
- Annual Distribution: $0.4115
- Annual Distribution Yield: 2.03%
iShares Diversified Monthly Income ETF
iShares Diversified Monthly Income ETF (ETF details) provides monthly income with an MER of 0.56%. As it happens, the ETF is a super ETF in that it’s built from many ETFs. This ETF appears much more appealing than the other mutual funds from a cost perspective.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.05
- Annual Distribution: $0.60
- Annual Distribution Yield: 5.29%
BMO Monthly Income ETF
BMO Monthly Income ETF (TSE:ZMI) (ETF Detail) has an MER of 0.55% beating the BMO Monthly Income Fun MER by 1%. Why buy the mutual fund? If you have a discount broker that offers free ETF transactions, you have no fees.
- Monthly Distribution: $0.056
- Annual Distribution: $0.672
- Annual Distribution Yield: 4.23%
Monthly Dividend Stocks
There are monthly dividend stocks but don’t hesitate to build a portfolio that can pay you regular quarterly income. When spread, it does still provide a decent monthly income, see my dividend income reports.
Monthly Income Considerations
As you can see, all of the products offer similar holdings with varying ratios but yet, the MER varies along with the yield. It can get confusing when you look at the yield to understand how it’s generated since return of capital or covered calls come into play and it’s not easily quantifiable.
Use your judgement and don’t be too greedy on the yield. Asset managers are generally rewarded based on short term performance rather than long term. If the yield is higher than what highest dividend paying stock, than you can be sure there is return of capital or covered calls used. Simplicity went out the window.
One big question to ask yourself is if you just want the income or if you want growth in the product or both. As you saw with the bonds graph above, interest rates have a major impact on both fixed income and dividend stocks. The higher the interest rate, the more fixed income will be purchased and vice versa. Investors will seek security with high interest rates when available. Establish your goals for your monthly income investment and review regularly.
When in doubt, compare to a Canadian Bank stock :)